Indianapolis Colts 2025 NFL Betting Odds & Picks
The 2025 season will begin with a sad note for the Indianapolis Colts. Owner Jim Irsay passed away on May 21. He was a visible and personable owner who made the Colts relevant, a perennial Super Bowl contender, and the 2006 world champions. His daughters are expected to take command of the franchise. One of them, Carlie Irsay-Gordon, is presumed to be taking over football operations.
The Indianapolis Colts have swapped out quarterbacks like flat tires every year since the sudden retirement of Andrew Luck. In Anthony Richardson, the Colts thought that they had one of the most thrilling prospects in all of football. Instead, he will be fighting for his job when training camp opens for the 2025 season.
QB Daniel Jones was sent packing by the New York Giants and will get a second lease on life in Indianapolis, where the pressure and media microscope are far less invasive. Jones parlayed a strong 2022 season into a massive contract, but it was all downhill from there. How much of the failure was his fault, or the lack of a supporting cast, remains to be seen.
Since 2015, the Colts have made two playoff appearances, the most recent one in 2020. However, Indianapolis has become one of the most mediocre franchises in football.
NFL Betting Lines
Ready to Bet on the Colts?
Bleed Blue, ready to horseshoe up and win big? Bet Indianapolis Colts 2025 NFL odds at BookMaker—spread bets, totals, player props, and futures all season long.
* Trusted by sharp bettors for over 30 years
* Early odds, fast payouts, and Bitcoin betting
* Live betting and mobile-optimized sportsbook
* Don’t just watch the action — bet on it!
* Sign Up Now and lock in your Colts picks today!
2025 Indianapolis Colts Schedule, Results & Record
Indy's secondary was rough in 2024, allowing 229.4 passing yards per game during the regular season (seventh-worst in the NFL). Given that glaring weakness, it makes sense that it was a main emphasis during free agency, with corner Charvarius Ward and safety Camryn Bynum brought in. Their arrivals instantly raised the floor of the pass defense.
While the Colts did a good job fixing the secondary, gamblers have some serious questions about the offensive line. Despite losing Ryan Kelly and Will Fries in free agency, they didn't take a lineman until the fourth round (Jordan Travis, OT, Iowa State).
Meanwhile, there is now a looming quarterback battle with Daniel Jones coming in to compete with Anthony Richardson. But if Jones actually wins the job, will the Colts truly be happy with that outcome? That means their former No. 4 overall quarterback in Richardson, is a lost cause.
Indianapolis Colts Past Seasons (2000)
| YEAR |
RECORD |
PLAYOFFS |
| 2024 |
8-9 |
None |
| 2023 |
9-8 |
None |
| 2022 |
4-12-1 |
None |
| 2021 |
9-8 |
None |
| 2020 |
11-5 |
Lost Wild Card Round |
| 2019 |
7-9 |
None |
| 2018 |
10-6 |
Lost Divisional Round |
| 2017 |
4-12 |
None |
| 2016 |
8-8 |
None |
| 2015 |
8-8 |
None |
| 2014 |
11-5 |
Lost Conference Championship |
| 2013 |
11-5 |
Lost Divisional Round |
| 2012 |
11-5 |
Lost Wild Card Round |
| 2011 |
2-14 |
None |
| 2010 |
10-6 |
Lost Wild Card Round |
| 2009 |
14-2 |
Lost Super Bowl |
| 2008 |
12-4 |
Lost Wild Card Round |
| 2007 |
13-3 |
Lost Divisional Round |
| 2006 |
12-4 |
Won Super Bowl |
| 2005 |
14-2 |
Lost Divisional Round |
| 2004 |
12-4 |
Lost Divisional Round |
| 2003 |
12-4 |
Lost Conference Championship |
| 2002 |
10-6 |
Lost Wild Card Round |
| 2001 |
6-10 |
None |
| 2000 |
10-6 |
Lost Wild Card Round |
In 1984, during the middle of the night, the Baltimore Colts snuck out of town with Mayflower moving vans to take up residence in Indianapolis, Indiana. For Baltimore fans, it was a personal tragedy. For residents of the Hoosier State, the Colts gave them a much-needed big-league status.
The Baltimore Colts were one of the most successful franchises in NFL history. Led by the famed Johnny Unitas at quarterback, the Colts put the NFL on the map with their overtime win at the New York Giants in the 1958 championship game. The Colts also suffered the greatest upset loss in history. In Super Bowl III, the New York Jets defeated the Colts 16-7 as 18.5-point underdogs. Baltimore went on to win Super Bowl V two years later.
Since 1995, the Colts have been one of the most successful franchises in pro football. Indianapolis has missed the playoffs just nine times since then. Of course, much of that success was due to Peyton Manning, who led them to two Super Bowl appearances with one win. Indeed, Lucas Oil Stadium is the House that Peyton Built.
Did You Know?
At BookMaker, we go beyond just providing top-notch sports betting options! Take advantage of these exclusive features and rewards:
BookMaker ATM Card for seamless transactions: Easily access your funds with the BookMaker ATM card, providing instant access to your winnings and secure transactions wherever you go.
Loyalty Levels & BetPoints Programs for additional rewards: Earn BetPoints as you bet, and unlock exciting perks at higher loyalty levels. The more you play, the more you earn!
Seasonal and Reload Bonuses to maximize your earnings: Stay ahead with seasonal promotions and reload bonuses, boosting your bankroll throughout the year.
Early Cashout Option for added flexibility: Cash out your bet early and lock in profits or limit losses—putting you in control of your wagers.
Free Crypto Payouts for fast and secure withdrawals: Enjoy fast, secure withdrawals with zero fees when you choose crypto payouts.
Open Play Option for unique parlay betting: Get creative with your parlays using the Open Play option, offering more ways to win.
Casino Promotions & Contests for extra fun and wins: Join in on exclusive casino promotions and contests, adding excitement to your betting experience.
8% Cash Back on all your horse racing bets: Place horse racing bets and get 8% cash back on your losses, making it easier to bounce back.
Explore all these benefits and more at BookMaker!
Betting Rules & Policies
Free Play Rules
- Free plays cannot be used on proposition bets.
- Free Plays do not earn any BetPoints™
- Bets made using Free Plays do not count towards completing any rollovers. (Free Plays are always subject to a rollover of their own. You must complete the required rollover prior to making a withdrawal).
- The maximum payout for any Free Play is $5,000.
- Free Plays that are left unused for 180 days will be removed from your account.
ROLLOVER
- Did you know that on all deposits made at BookMaker, there is a rollover requirement: an amount of betting action you must fulfill before you are eligible to make a withdrawal.
- Did you know that rollovers are calculated by multiplying the amount initially credited to your account a certain number of times? Yes! If you deposit without claiming any bonus, the rollover will always be 1x (one-time) your deposit amount. If you do claim a deposit bonus, the rollover will be higher and is based on the deposit plus bonus amount.
Wager disputes (claims)
If you disagree with any aspect of a wager you’ve placed, you are welcome to log an official dispute (commonly known as a “claim”). Claims must be reported no later than 15 (fifteen) calendar days following the settlement of the wager.
If following an initial review of the case there remains any doubt regarding the wager type, line, market, amount, or any other detail, the claim will be escalated to the BookMaker management team. All decisions made by them are final.
Wager Cash Out - How it works
With the Cash Out feature you can choose to eliminate a wager that's already been placed, and receive back either a portion, or your full stake amount.
Cash Out is selectively available on certain events, fixtures, and markets.
In order to see if a wager is eligible to be cashed out, simply navigate to your Bet Slip and check the 'My Open Bets' tab. If eligible, the Cash Out button will be displayed.
It’s also important to note that Cash Out is not contributing to any bonus or promotion including Bet Point accumulation and Rollover for releasing bonus cash.
